Matthew 24:36–44
Grace and peace to you from our God, who created us, redeemed us, and moves among us still. Amen.
Church, believe it or not, tomorrow is December, and we are busy are decking the halls, humming along to carols, making lists, baking cookies, and planning gatherings. It’s a season filled with warmth and beauty and anticipation.
And then we come to church and hear this text. Matthew and the Jesus he presents to us seem not at all interested in Christmas, but instead on an apocalyptic day in the unknown future, when the Son of Man will come again, abruptly and decisively reshaping our lives. He talks about people disappearing and a thief in the night. It’s almost like Matthew didn’t get the memo about the hot cocoa and twinkle lights, and the dawn that will break with Baby Jesus in that manger.
But maybe that’s exactly why we need this text in Advent. Because it invites us to tell the truth: that the world we’re living in is beautiful, yes – but also weary, anxious, fractured, uncertain. And Advent has always spoken honestly into that kind of world.
The first readers of Matthew’s Gospel lived in a very unstable world. Only a generation after Jesus’ life, they were reeling from the destruction of the temple in Jerusalem. These were Jewish Christians who were hoping, expecting, anticipating Jesus’ return and were looking for some assurance about what was to come. Looking for ways to make sense of the political and religious chaos around them. They longed for clarity and reassurance – hope that the promises of God would hold, that Jesus would return, and that the turmoil around them was not the final word.
Matthew’s Gospel offers them (and us) a vision of God’s faithfulness, a reminder that even when the world feels unstable, God’s story continues, and we are part of it.
Those of us listening today are now millennia removed from this moment in Matthew, yet our own time is also fractured – frightening, politically charged, economically uncertain, and religiously divided. And because we are hearing these words today, it matters to name the lens many of us carry: a Christian landscape shaped by the Left Behind series or by preachers and public voices who used passages like this to stir fear.
Rapture theology – the idea that God will scoop up a select few and abandon the rest – is not Lutheran theology. It isn’t historically Christian theology. And it isn’t what Jesus is teaching here.
Still, because we hear this text in this particular moment in time, it’s hard not to feel that undercurrent of threat: that if you aren’t faithful enough, or if you don’t correctly predict “the end,” you’ll be left behind.
As hard as it is, I want to invite you to gently lay that fear to the side so we can listen to what Jesus is actually saying to his disciples – and to us – today.
What sounds scary to our ears, like this image of a thief in the night, believe it or not was good news to those early listeners. Because the question is not “How will Jesus come like a thief?” the question is: “To whom does Jesus’ coming feel like a threat?”
Jesus’ promise is a threat to anything that crushes the vulnerable. Any structure that profits from suffering. Any shame that tells us we are unworthy. Any ideology that divides or dehumanizes. Any cruelty that belittles our neighbor or ourselves.
Those things should be afraid. Because when Christ comes – both someday and right now – he steals them away. He breaks into our world not to harm, but to liberate. Not to destroy us, but to dismantle everything that destroys life. Judgment, in Matthew, is good news for the oppressed.
Jesus isn’t giving us a play-by-play of the end of the world. He isn’t offering secret clues for decoding headlines or signs. He isn’t giving us charts and timelines. In fact, the very first thing he says is that no one knows. Not the angels, not the disciples, not even Jesus himself. And that should release the pressure on us to have it all figured out.
Just like these first-century Christians, we of course want guarantees about the future. We want to know that our families will be okay, that the world will settle down, that our health will hold out, that our kids will thrive, that our country won’t fall apart, that the churches will stay strong and grow.
And the truth is: We don’t know. We can’t know. And today Jesus simply says, “Your job is not to know the future. Your job is to trust me in the present.”
He calls us to live faithfully in the present, to trust in God’s grace, and to pay attention to what God is doing here and now. Theologian Karl Barth that this “here and now” might be called “between the times.” We live with one foot plated in memory and one foot pointed toward promise, but rooted right here.
We look back, as Jesus does in this passage – remembering the mighty acts of God in scripture. And we look forward – to a promised future we haven’t fully seen: to a world made whole, a creation healed, and every tear wiped away. But we live right here, in the middle, where the world is still messy and God is still working.
We don’t fear the future because we have seen what God has done in the past. Even when humanity lost its way, God remained faithful. And God still is. Remembering this helps us to live “between the times” with courage.
Notice where Jesus keep his attention and where he locates discipleship: in the field, at the mill, in the daily grind, in the normal routines of life. The mundane is where faithfulness happens and it is not to be neglected. These “between times” are the totality of our lived lives. Our every day. Biblical faith knows that it does not know everything, but it does know that it’s called to do something here and now.
Jesus does not give up on this world and neither should we. “Keep awake,” he says. Not out of fear, but because God shows up in the ordinary places we’re most likely to overlook. To be awake is to be present, to be compassionate, to notice the people right in front of us. To be awake is to refuse apathy in a world that numbs us with noise. To care deeply about one another.
So Advent, today, is a three-fold movement:
We remember God’s faithfulness in the past.
We trust God’s promise for the future.
We act with love in the present.
We don’t know how or when God will bring the new creation to fulfillment, but we do know that it has already begun. And we know that the same God who healed and saved and liberated in scripture is still doing that today. The same God who claimed us in baptism still calls us beloved now. The same Christ who broke bread with his disciples, gathers with us right here at this table. The same God who promised a world made new is already breaking into our ordinary, here among us still.
Thanks be to God. Amen.